> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://brookevitale.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# What is Line Editing: How it Fits into the Editorial Process
- URL: https://brookevitale.com/blog/line-editing/
- Published: 2022-03-22T10:53:45.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-09T20:15:12.000Z
- Description: A detailed explanation of line editing, including when it occurs, and how it differs from editorial assessment and copy edit with real world manuscript examples.
- Author: Andrew Vitale
- Tags: Editing

## What is line editing?

Line editing is a thorough, line by line review of a manuscript that assesses word choice, sentence structure, story tense, point of view, and overall flow of a story. The point of a line edit is to tighten up a manuscript while staying true to a writer’s voice. Although editors can all agree on what line editing is, they do not always agree on what it is called. Line editing can also be called substantive editing, structural editing, or developmental editing. Personally, I perform line editing as part of the developmental editing stage, which comes after my big-picture notes in the editorial assessment. To understand what a developmental edit is, check out my article [What Is Developmental Editing and What to Expect From One](https://brookevitale.com/blog/developmental-edit/).

## Line editing vs. editorial assessment

Line editing is all about the fine details. A line edit’s job is to ensure that every word is perfect and conveys exactly the sentiment an author is trying to get across. An editorial assessment, by comparison, is all about the big picture. Editorial assessments look at overall story arc and seek out big-picture issues that need to be resolved before a line edit can occur. Performing these stages of editing in the right order is essential, as line editing text with major issues and plot holes is a waste of both time and money.

> Pro Tip: Like line editing, editorial assessments can go by many names. While I use this term because this stage is assessing a manuscript for flaws, others call this stage a developmental edit. For more information about editorial assessments, check out my article [What is an Editorial Assessment with Real World Examples](https://brookevitale.com/blog/what-is-an-editorial-assessment/).

## Line editing vs. copy editing

Line editing seeks to shape a story. A line edit sharpens a writer’s work, and can be quite substantive in the changes suggested. Part of a line editor’s job is to make changes—to find the places the story needs to be fixed and to make those changes. But it is important to know that these changes are subjective. Three line editors reviewing a manuscript will likely come back with three different sets of notes and suggestions. And none of these suggestions will be any more “correct” than the other.

Copy editing, on the other hand, is all about precision. Copy editors follow particular industry style guides and publishing house style guides. The copy editor’s job is to ensure that the spelling and grammar choices in a manuscript align with those style guides. Copy editing is not meant to propose new ways to phrase a sentence, but rather to ensure that the sentence is grammatically correct, with no typos. Copy editing is not a subjective practice. It is particular and follows specific rules. Three top-notch copy editors looking at the same manuscript should all come back with exactly the same set of changes to a manuscript. For more information on copy editing, and how it differs from proofreading, check out [What's the Difference Between Copy Editing and Proofreading?](https://brookevitale.com/blog/what-is-copy-editing/)

Because copy editing is checking for final errors in a manuscript, it occurs after a line edit.

> Pro Tip: Always confirm with any editor exactly what will be included in any stage of editing. Because different editors use different terms, this is the only way to be certain you are hiring an editor for the work that is actually needed.

## Line editing examples

The truth is, line editing never looks the same twice. While some changes made in the line editing process are minor, others can be far more substantial. No two manuscripts are the same, and the kinds of changes suggested vary from book to book. Which makes it nearly impossible to call out everything line editing looks for. But it is not impossible to show what line editing looks like! Below are some examples of the edits I did on the picture book [*Oliver and the Wishing Star*](https://www.amazon.com/Oliver-Wishing-Star-Jennifer-Decker/dp/1737764407/?ref=brookevitale.com)by Jennifer Decker.

In the example below, you can see the changes made to the opening of the book. The original manuscript began with a long introduction and a conversation between Oliver and Mom about his day. But in line editing the book, I condensed this down. One of the jobs of a line edit is to make sure the reader is engaged from the very first line of a book. Those first lines of a book need to grab a reader’s attention and to throw them directly into the action. The edited lines do exactly that, removing the build up and setting up exactly what Oliver wants: to go to his friend’s house.

![A line editing example: condensing an opening](https://storage.ghost.io/c/bb/ca/bbca9709-f64c-426c-94c5-41deebbf6557/content/images/2026/10/1080w-line-editing-example-concise-opening.jpg)

The new lines immediately following the opening paragraph put the reader into Oliver’s head. They allow us to see that he knows he shouldn’t be going out, but that he hopes to get away with it anyway. These lines add a heightened emotion to the story that make the reader sympathize with Oliver, rather than just watching him walk out the door. After all, what child hasn’t wanted to do something they know they shouldn’t? What child hasn’t longed for that sense of freedom, to go do what they want, rather than follow the rules? The change in these lines transforms the text from a case of “telling the reader what is happening” to “showing the reader what is happening.”

All too often, authors get caught up in the idea of narrating everything that happens, and forget to look at the underlying emotion. And having read a manuscript hundreds of times, it can be impossible to see when it is happening. Finding and teasing out these scenes to read in the best possible fashion is the job of a line editor, whose fresh eyes can see what an author’s eyes can no longer find.

> Pro Tip: For more information on how to show more in your writing, check out my article, [Show, Don't Tell—A Guide to Stronger Writing, with Examples](https://brookevitale.com/blog/show-dont-tell/).

Now take a look at a passage from later in the book, when Oliver is walking his dog. Here, a few kinds of line edits appear.

![Various types of line editing examples](https://storage.ghost.io/c/bb/ca/bbca9709-f64c-426c-94c5-41deebbf6557/content/images/2026/10/1080w-line-editing-examples-comparisons.jpg)

First, you’ll see that I added the words, “The farther they went” to the opening of this section. The addition of this language adds the implication that time is passing. Because this is clearly something that is on Oliver’s mind, and bothering him, we want to show that it’s not just a passing thought, but something he is putting serious thought into. As with above, this heightens the emotion of the moment.

Second, I replaced “Society labels us as dogs’ masters” with “I know we’re supposed to be the dogs’ masters.” This change was made because the character is a young child. Kids of this age do not speak so formally, or often use such big words. And very few would know the word “society.” Especially when it comes to children’s books, a line edit should ensure that language is age appropriate. But even outside of children’s books, a line edit ensures that the words someone says are true ot their personality and character—that they would truly say the words being put in their mouth.

Finally, the second paragraph in the original document was removed. I did this because that paragraph was interfering with the flow of Oliver’s rant. In reality, he would not stop midway through. He would build up steam, breath coming faster, words coming louder. As a line editor, I wanted to reflect that accurately, without breaking up his speech to show what was happening. Telling the reader that he is shouting isn’t needed when it can be SEEN in the text.

The final example below demonstrates a simpler line edit. Here, rather than restructuring text, I simply moved a line of text down for better flow.

![A storyflow line editing example](https://storage.ghost.io/c/bb/ca/bbca9709-f64c-426c-94c5-41deebbf6557/content/images/2026/10/1080w-line-editing-example-storyflow.jpg)

By shifting down Oliver’s desire to swap places with his dog, the first paragraph instead calls out not only that Cooper has it good, but WHY he has it so good. Beginning with a list of all the reasons Cooper’s life is better than Oliver’s provides a logical transition to the idea that Oliver would be better off swapping lives with Cooper.

These examples, while not showcasing every kind of change a line editor can make paint a strong picture of what line editing is and how it changes a manuscript. But they do leave one thing out: a line editor is only as good as their understanding of the text and the author’s motivations. Not every editor is the right fit for every book. Before hiring an editor to line edit your book, ask for a sample edit. Make sure they have a good feel for you and for your book, and that you are happy with the work they deliver back. At the end of the day, a line editor is an author’s best ally in ensuring a manuscript lives up to its full potential. So make sure to select one whom you can trust to see your vision through and shape it into its best version.