5 Steps to Cut Text in a Picture Book
Contents
Most picture book authors have heard the rule: A picture book should not exceed 1,000 words. And many have looked at their word count and said, “Now what?” So, when it comes to word count, is a thousand words really a hard-and-fast rule? And more importantly, how can you trim your book down when you love every word of it?
Can I exceed 1,000 words?
The answer to this comes down to your intent for the book. If you plan to look for an agent and, eventually, a publisher, the answer is no. In fact, many agents will reject a book without even reading it if they see that it has more than a thousand words. These days the sweet spot for a picture book going through a publisher is closer to 500–700 words.
If you intend to self-publish, you have more wiggle room. In truth, your book can be as long as you want it to be. But do keep in mind that while your book needs to engage the child for whom it’s intended, it also needs to keep the interest of the adult doing the reading. As the mom of a three-year-old and a five-year-old, I can tell you that there are plenty of books on our shelves that my kids love and I dread reading because they are simply too long. And let me tell you, those have a funny way of suddenly ending up anywhere other than my boys’ rooms!
So, how can I trim a book that’s too long? With these 5 steps!
Cut your descriptions
Hands-down, one of the biggest mistakes picture book authors make is using language that is too descriptive. When writing, always keep in mind the one big difference between a picture book and a chapter book or novel: Pictures! With books for older readers, it is up to the reader to visualize the scene. But with a picture book, every page comes with full art. And what that means is that you don’t need to tell your reader what things look like!
It can be tempting to offer a full description of your protagonist—to tell us what color her hair is, what color her eyes are, and what kind of outfit she’s wearing. But unless that outfit is essential to the story, we don’t need to hear about it in the text. Your protagonist’s hair and eye color, as well as their outfit, will be apparent in the art, so save yourself the words and let the art do the talking for you. The same is true of your character’s emotional state. Can we see in the art that they are sad? How about that they are laughing? If so, consider whether or not you really need to tell the reader that, or whether they can see it for themselves.
Of course, that doesn’t mean no descriptions should be used. They should be, but use them wisely. For example, the reader doesn’t necessarily need to know that a character’s car is red. But if a red car was involved in an accident and the police are chasing it, by all means tell the reader what color the car is. That will help them to spot it in the art, which will aid in telling the story.
It’s all about being concise!
Are your words all truly contributing to the story, or do you have extraneous material in there that could be cut without your story suffering? Are you using fifteen words to say something you could say in five? With picture books, keep your sentences short and to the point. The longer they get, the more likely they are to contain words that you really don’t need.
The same is true of your scenes. Try plotting out your story with only the moments that are essential to the big payoff at the end. Is there something sitting in there that really isn’t needed? Something that, while enjoyable, doesn’t move your story forward. Long stories usually have at least one moment that truly isn’t needed, whether because it doesn’t move the story toward its inevitable conclusion or because it actually slows the story down. And, more often than not, that scene is a holdover from a previous draft—something that is near and dear to your heart, but that no longer serves the story. Those moments can be hard to cut, but if they aren’t serving a purpose, it’s time for them to go.
Cut down on the action!
No, not the actual action of your story. Cut down on the physical actions your characters make as they move through a scene. If your character is angry, it’s enough to see them slam their bedroom door. The reader doesn’t need to also see your protagonist throw the front door open and stomp down the hall. If your protagonist is heading to the store, it’s enough to see them buy what they need (or even walk inside or look at the front window if that’s important to your story) but your reader doesn’t need to see the character get into the car, stop at the stop sign, get out of the car, or walk through the parking lot. Just because it physically moves your character forward doesn’t mean it actually furthers your story.
Check out the book’s pagination
Once you feel like the story is in a good place, try paginating the book. Figuring out what text is meant to go on what page, and where your page turns go, will help you find any scene that still doesn’t fit. Even better, it will help you find the pages that have too much text. A good rule of thumb is to limit yourself to 50 words per page (or even less if you can). It can be hard looking at a long manuscript to find places to cut. Seeing just how many words you have on each page may give you a fresh perspective on how to trim. For a deeper dive into pagination check out A Template for Children's Book Layout and Pagination.
Try reading it aloud
When all else fails, try reading your story aloud. Better yet, have someone else read it aloud it you. There’s something about hearing the story in a different way that can bring clarity. Listening to the story out loud may help you find places that aren’t working, or that aren’t needed.
Once you’ve done all you can to get your book whipped into shape, it’s time to show it to someone else. As tempting as it may be to make that person a friend or family member, remember that they love you and will likely tell you the story is great. Instead, find an editor, a beta-reader, or a member of a writing group—someone who is familiar with picture books and can really help you find the strengths and weaknesses of your story!


