How to Self-Edit: Editing Tips to Improve Your Writing
Contents
What is self-editing?
Self-editing is when an author corrects their own mistakes in a manuscript, revises the structure, and perfects word-choice. Self-editing typically comes before a professional editor begins work on a book, but even after an editor has done their work, an author may continue self-editing. Why? Because self-editing isn’t just a single review. It’s many reviews over time. First after a rough draft of a manuscript. Then after beta readers or author critiques. And again after an editor looks over a book. The point of self-editing is to get a book as perfect as it can be before it goes to a professional editor, and to give it that last shine before going to the printer (or to a literary agent or book publisher.) For more information on what an actual editor does on a book, check out my articles What Is an Editorial Assessment with Real World Examples and Developmental Edit. So buckle up and get ready to be your own harshest critic, because self-editing is all about being honest with yourself. But you don’t have to do it alone. Belo we break down some tips and techniques for self-editing a book, from the best ways to find mistakes to the actual mistakes you’re looking for.
How to self-edit
Whether you are preparing a book to go to a literary agent or book publisher, a professional editor, or can’t afford an editor and need to do everything yourself, self-editing is a crucial step of the book-writing and book-publishing process. But as a novice, how can an author know what to look for? With this easy-to-follow checklist!
Start strong
As an editor, I see so many books that don’t really start until several paragraphs or pages into the story. And while that is fine in a rough draft, it doesn’t work for a polished story. Readers want to get into the action right away. They want to be drawn in from page one, line one. (Think about your favorite first lines of books. What are they?) Once the book is written, take a step back and see where your action starts. Remember, the best books offer context on the scene, set up a conflict, or throw a reader into a mystery right from the start. So make sure you aren’t meandering and losing your audience before you even catch their attention.
Ditch the unnecessary words
It’s not uncommon for a first draft of a book to go off on wild tangents. Especially if an author is just focused on getting the words out, the end result may contain a ton of unnecessary scenes or descriptions. And that’s fine! That’s what a first draft is for: getting all those thoughts out. But in self-editing, it is time to start looking for those added words and scenes. No one will complain about an overly long book if every word matters. But an overly long book that goes so far afield you forget the story? That’s something else entirely. No matter the kind of book, every word counts, so use your words wisely.
Pro Tip: If you’re writing a picture book, remember that the ideal word count is between 500 and 700 words, and a manuscript should not exceed 1,000 words. One way to clear out the unnecessary words is by removing anything that describes the art the reader will already be able to see. For more tips on cutting text in a picture book, check out my article, 5 Steps to Cut Text in a Picture Book.
Get rid of unnecessary scenes or characters
As a book develops, often what was once important loses significance. In self-editing, look for characters who no longer need to be there for a story to make sense. Look for scenes that don’t further the story in any way. And look for background information that doesn’t inform who the protagonist or antagonist is today. The fact that a character lived in a white house when they were ten years old doesn’t matter unless part of their story arc is returning to that house and seeing how it has changed.
Redundancies in language
Beware adjectives!
One of the worst offenders of redundant words are adjectives. Often author will use several adjectives in a row that all essentially mean the same thing. For example, calling an ant a “tiny ant” or even worse a “very tiny ant.” All ants are tiny, so using both adjectives is just repetitive. (Unless of course he is significantly smaller than all of the others, in which case that ant would be tiny compared to the others.)
Watch out also for the word very. It tends to creep into language where it truly isn’t needed!
Take note, also, of the words you use in relation to timing. It’s tempting to move a story along with the words “Suddenly” or “Just then,” but using those words too often can drag a story down. Try to find varied ways of moving time along.
Pro Tip: When self-editing, keep track of how often you use words like “very” or “suddenly.” Try to track whether you are starting too many sentences with “And” or “But.” One of the best ways to do this is to do a find-and-replace. See where these words come up in a manuscript and try to replace them with something fresh.
Turns of phrase
Turns of phrase can also lead to redundancies. One of the biggest ones is the expression “in order to,” which is usually not needed. The sentence “He went to the store in order to buy eggs.” is redundant. We know that’s why he went to the store. So simply saying “He went to the store to buy eggs,” works just as well.
Clarity
This is, hands-down, one of the most challenging parts of self-editing. Why? Because as the author, you KNOW what you want to say. You know the extra information that is in your head, even if a reader doesn’t. And you wrote the words, so they make perfect sense to you. But that doesn’t mean they make perfect sense to an outsider. It’s hard to do, but try to read your book with fresh eyes. Try to see it like a new reader would. Does what you’re saying make sense? Does it convey what it needs to, either in terms of plot or emotion? If you’re not sure, take step back. Wait a few days and read it again. Or ask someone who hasn’t read the book to read it and see if any questions arise.
Passive voice
Passive voice means that the subject is having an action done TO them. For example: The boy was chased by the dog. Here, the chasing is being done TO the boy.
Written in active voice, the sentence might read: The dog chased the boy.
Sentences in active voice are clear and direct. They are in the moment, as with the sentence above. The chase is happening NOW. We are watching it unfold. Stories are more exciting when in active voice, so try to find those moments of passive voice and turn them around. For a comprehensive guide to what "Show, Don't Tell" means, how to show rather than tell, and how showing can make you a better writer, and your book a better book, with show don't tell examples of what to do and what not to do, check out my article Show, Don't Tell—A Guide to Stronger Writing, with Examples.
Pro Tip: Passive voice can be a tough one for authors to find, but there’s good news. Grammar checkers will call this out for you. I personally like to run a spell check on Microsoft Word. If I see passive sentences, I’ll search out a few paragraphs at a time to track them down and correct them to be active.
Verb tense
This is another big one. All too often, authors will flip back and forth between past and present tense. This is not only grammatically incorrect, it can be confusing for a reader. Read through your book with a careful eye to verb tense. If you’ve started in past tense, is every verb in past tense? If you suddenly shift to present, it’s time to make a change!
Dialogue tags
The word “said” exists for a reason. It’s because it fades to the back of a sentence. Be aware in writing of your dialogue tags and how often you are using louder tags. Shouted, cheered, yelled . . . These draw more attention to HOW language is being said than to WHAT is being said. And the point is WHAT is being said—usually. Sometimes HOW does matter, but rarely. So try to get comfortable with the word “said” and make it your dominant dialogue tag. The same is true for “asked.” That is sufficient. Characters don’t need to query, inquire, or ponder with every sentence. It just becomes a distraction.
On the flip side, also make sure you aren’t using “said” in every sentence. There are ways to set up a sentence so no dialogue tag is needed at all.
For more information on how to effectively use dialogue tags, check out my article 5 Tips to Write Dialouge Effectively .
Show versus tell
There isn’t an author out there who hasn’t heard this one. Show, don’t tell. But what does that mean? It means that as readers we don’t just want to be observers. We want to be in the moment and in a character’s head. We want to feel what they feel.
Tell: Alice was devastated as she watched him leave.
Show: Tears streamed down Alice’s face as she watched him walk away. Her knees buckled underneath her and she sunk to the ground as the only person she had ever loved disappeared out of sight.
Here we get a stronger sense of the emotion. Of what she is thinking and feeling and of how this man leaving is affecting her. Strive in all of your language to SHOW a scene, rather than just telling the reader what is happening.
Sentence structure
In writing a book, it's important not just to vary language, but to vary sentence structure. Take a look at the following passage:
Climbing the tree, he reached for the branch. Swinging, he kicked his feet up. Laughing, he dropped to the ground.
Note how every sentence starts the same way? Now take a look at the same sentiment, written differently:
Climbing the tree, he reached for the branch. His fingers grazed the thin sliver of wood, and he kicked his feet up. A laugh filled his throat as he swung once and then dropped to the ground.
Better, right? More interesting? Using the same structure over and over starts to feel redundant. Keep an eye out for sentence structure to make sure it is varied. Playing with sentence structure will improve readability and flow. And while you’re at it, make sure you don’t have any crazy long run-on sentences!
Spelling and grammar
It seems obvious: any author should strive to avoid typos and grammar mistakes. And yet, it’s amazing how many published books are riddled with mistakes. The longer a book, the more likely mistakes are to happen, and even traditional publishers miss some things. But as an author, do yourself a favor and read closely for these mistakes. And take advantage of resources available to you to check them. Microsoft Word and GoogleDocs both have spelling-check and grammar-check features. (They aren’t perfect, but they are a start!) And a quick Google search will yield multiple web services that offer free and paid spelling and grammar-check services, including Grammarly, Ginger, and Hemingway Editor to name a few.
Pro Tip: Be careful with the grammar services. While they can get grammar correct, they do not do well with capturing an author’s voice, so consider each suggestion carefully before deciding to accept the change.
Formatting
Whether you are preparing your book for a printer, a designer, or an agent, make sure your formatting is correct. Books should contain a single space between periods, and new paragraphs should be indented using the margins tools in your word processing document, not by tabbing or spacing over. To submit to a publisher, make sure the document is double spaced and written in a clean font, like Times New Roman or Arial, in 12-point font.
What are the best ways to self-edit?
Knowing what to look for is great, but what are the best ways to find it? After all, you probably think your book is perfect as-is! Chek out the xx tips below. Not all of these will work for everyone, but give them all a shot anyway. You might find a method of self-editing you didn’t know could work for you!
Read out loud
It’s amazing the problems you’ll catch when you’re reading out loud! While you can skip over things and gloss over mistakes in your mind, your mouth doesn’t tend to let you do that. Which is why reading aloud is such a great way to tell where you’re stumbling.
Pro Tip: If you’re writing a children’s book, ask a child to read it out loud. See where they stumble.
Print it out
Our eyes tend to gloss over mistakes on a screen. But in print they are more glaring. Sit down with a print out—and a red pencil! Then get to work finding those areas that don’t sit right.
Take a break
It’s impossible to self-edit a book right after you finish it. In that moment, you are sure it’s great. (Or you’re sure it’s garbage.) Take some time away. Read a new book. Get some exercise. Then come back a few days later with fresh eyes.
Author critiques/workshops
Work with other authors who write in the same genre as you. Do a book exchange and critique each other’s work. Make sure to come at their notes with an open mind. You might not like they feedback you get, but it comes from a place of improving your book.
Pro Tip: If you are writing children’s books, try scheduling a school visit to read to kids and show them your work in progress. Schools love author visits!
Remember your audience
No matter how much you love your book, you aren’t the audience for it. So keep in mind who is, and what they are looking for in a book. This is especially true of children’s books, where you need to keep in mind reading level and what kids of that age can actually understand. For more information on what makes a good picture book, check out What is a Picture Book and What Makes a Good Picture Book. For more information on target audiences for children’s books, check out my article Target Audience.
Get comfortable with style guides
Style guides are a great way to keep track of characters, setting, timelines, and spelling choices. Learn how to use and create style guides to make sure your book is consistent throughout. For more information on style guides, check out my article, Why Is a Style Guide Essential to Writing a Series?
Be honest with yourself
This is the hardest part of self-editing. As authors, we love everything we right. But a key element of self-editing is being honest with ourselves about what isn’t working. Don’t be afraid to cut your favorite characters or scenes if they aren’t working, or to completely rework a scene to make it read more smoothly. Often our favorite scenes don’t make the final cut, but getting rid of them makes room for even better scenes.
Read it backward
When the time comes to proofread for spelling and grammar mistakes, try reading the book backward, either from the last page to the first, or even better, from the last WORD to the first. Reading out of order confuses your head and allow you to focus on the words and the spelling, rather than the meaning and the story.
For a quick guide, download my self-editing checklist. And remember, editing isn't a one-time thing. Books get edited and revised and edited many times. So do what you can, and then come back to the book with fresh eyes.


